Beer World, Lost Plots, Family Systems Theory and Church Conflict: A Discussion with Dr. Dave Miles (Part 2)
- Matthew Bohling
- Aug 16
- 2 min read
The Church Renewal Podcast recently featured a profound conversation with Dave Miles from Vital Church, exploring the systemic issues affecting modern churches and the critical importance of addressing emotional processes beneath surface-level problems. This episode reveals a troubling reality: many churches have fundamentally "lost the plot" of what it means to be the body of Christ in today's world.
One of the most striking revelations came through alarming statistics about church decline in America. According to Thom Rainer's research, approximately 15,000 churches are expected to close this year alone—about 50 closures daily. Another 15,000 congregations will be unable to afford a full-time pastor. By 2030, an estimated 25% of all pastors and churches in America will face retirement. These statistics aren't merely numbers; they represent a profound crisis of identity and sustainability in American Christianity.
The conversation pivoted to a foundational understanding that churches do not exist for themselves. Drawing from Matthew 16, the speakers explored how the church's purpose ties back to God's promise to Abraham—to be a blessing to all nations. This core mission has often been obscured by institutional thinking and self-preservation instincts. When churches lose sight of this outward-focused calling, they inevitably begin a process of decline, regardless of their programming or pastoral leadership.
Perhaps the most illuminating aspect of the discussion centered on Family Systems Theory and its application to church dynamics. Dave and the hosts shared how this psychological framework helped them understand that surface-level conflicts in churches typically mask deeper emotional processes and unexamined patterns. "What looks like the problem is never the problem, ever," Dave emphasized, noting that underneath many church conflicts lies unaddressed idolatry—the sin beneath the sin, the issue beneath the issue.
The conversation highlighted how unexamined family-of-origin issues impact church leadership. Leaders often bring their own unprocessed emotional baggage into church systems, creating reactive patterns that perpetuate dysfunction. Without addressing these underlying emotional processes, churches repeatedly treat symptoms rather than causes. This insight explains why many church interventions and "quick fixes" fail to produce lasting change—they never address the true root of problems.
A powerful hypothesis emerged near the end of the conversation: what every person ultimately seeks in church is love, acceptance, and belonging. Tragically, many find more genuine acceptance in secular spaces—like "Beer World" as playfully referenced—than in congregations that claim to represent Christ's unconditional love. The speakers noted how a misunderstanding of God's grace often leads to churches treating members with the same conditional acceptance they believe God extends to them. This creates environments where people feel they must perform to belong, directly contradicting the gospel's message of grace.
Comments